The Promise Europe News
GHF Food Distribution Shootings are a Potential Crime of War
The shootings at the GHF food distributions in Gaza, at which over 500 people have already been killed and thousands injured, are a violation of core humanitarian principles and can be considered a potential war crime, says our Executive Director Kate Mackintosh.
In an interview with Al Jazeera this morning she warns that GHF staff may be complicit in these war crimes and could potentially be prosecuted by many states around the world.
Introducing Ecocide, ABA Webinar
๐ Webinar Announcement: Introducing Ecocide โ Towards a New International Crime
๐
Wednesday, July 2, 2025
๐ 12:00โ1:30 PM ET
๐ Online (free & open to all)
Weโre pleased to share an important upcoming webinar hosted by the International Human Rights Committees of the American Bar Association (ABA) Sections on Civil Rights & Social Justice and International Law. This session will explore the legal, procedural, and moral case for recognizing ecocide as an international crime.
Borders and Belonging discussion at the International Institute of Social Studies
Immigration is a broad and complex topic. With his book Borders and Belonging, Professor Hiroshi Motomura offers a framework that helps deepen the conversation and foster meaningful dialogue, identifying the overlapping but distinct claims of humanity and belonging.
Stop ecocide in the ocean!
Our Executive Director, Kate Mackintosh joined a distinguished gathering in the margins of the United Nations Oceans Conference in Nice to discuss the importance of creating a crime of Ecocide.
Hosted by the states of Vanuatu and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the event included ministers, government officials and MPs from Ghana, Guatemala and Tahiti, united in their commitment to end the destruction of our shared environment.
Ecocide Bibliography Highlight
Ecocide in Peru: Repsol and the Colonial Regime of Permission, Ignasi Bernat Molina, Environmental Politics (May 2025).
This paper examines the 2022 Repsol oil spill in Peru as a case study, demonstrating how the disaster resulted from long-term decisions by both Spanish and Peruvian states. It argues that ecocide must be understood within a colonial matrix that enriches fossil capital while creating conditions for ecological destruction.
Ecocide Bibliography Highlight:
Thanks to the stellar work of our research assistants Ava Schuster and John Dover, our annotated bibliography on international criminal law and environmental protection is fully updated! Weโre excited to share the most powerful reads we have come across. Todayโs highlight:
The Destruction of Indigenous Communitiesโ Landscapes: An Aggravated Form of Ecocide? Jรฉrรดme de Hemptinne & Helena Szczupak, EJIL:Talk! (May 2025)
This piece explores whether peacetime industrial destruction of Indigenous landscapes constitutes an aggravated form of ecocide.
BBC Radio Scotland Interview Ecocide Bill
Our Executive Director Kate Mackintosh was honoured to assist Monica Lennon as a member of her expert advisory committee. She spoke to BBC Radio Scotland to explain the bill.
Seminar Invitation: Borders and Belonging โ Toward a Fair Immigration Policy
Date: June 12, 17:00 โ 21:00
Location: International Institute for Social Studies (ISS), The Hague
Please join us on June 12 for a seminar featuring UCLA Law Professor Hiroshi Motomura, who will present his most recent book:
Borders and Belonging โ Toward a Fair Immigration Policy
๐ Understanding the Elements of Ecocide Law: A Seven-Part Series ๐
Part 7: Liability of Legal Entities, Corporate Workers and Public Servants
Some new ecocide laws create liability for companies as well as individuals. These include those in the EU, Belgium and France.
This means that the legal entity as a whole, as opposed to natural persons within it, can be held accountable for environmental harm. This is important at the national level, where individuals might hide behind the โveilโ of the corporate structure to avoid liability.
๐ Understanding the Elements of Ecocide Law: A Seven-Part Series๐
Part 6: Creation of Harm or Risk?
Some crimes consist in bringing about harmful consequences, while others consist of creating a risk of harm. These offences of โendangerment,โ are committed regardless of whether the harm materialises.
๐ Understanding the Elements of Ecocide Law: A Seven-Part Series๐
Part 5: The Mental Element
Mens rea refers to the criminal intent or awareness a suspect has regarding the wrongfulness of their actions. In cases of environmental harm, the issue of mens rea is complex since potential violators rarely aim to cause environmental damage; rather, harm is a byproduct of profit-driven activities.
๐ Understanding the Elements of Ecocide Law: A Seven-Part Series ๐
Part 4: The Unlawfulness of Conduct
There is currently a debate over how a crime of ecocide at national level should relate to other environmental laws and regulations. If an act is not in violation of environmental regulations, can it still constitute the crime? This is less relevant at the international level, as the fact that something is permitted under national law does not exclude it from being an international crime.
๐ Understanding the Elements of Ecocide Law: A Seven-Part Series ๐
Part 3 : Prohibition of Acts vs Prohibition of Consequences
Most of the new legislation โ laws in Belgium and Jalisco(Mexico) and proposals in Mexico (federal), Brazil, the Netherlands, Italy, Peru, and Scotland โ describe the crime through the consequences of acts (or omissions), rather than listing prohibited acts. Acts amount to ecocide when and if they threaten or cause a certain level of harm to the environment. The International Proposal takes this approach, prohibiting acts which cause a substantial risk of harm without detailing which actions create that risk.
๐ Understanding the Elements of Ecocide Law: A Seven-Part Series ๐
Part 2: The Definition of Environment
As ecocide encompasses harm to the environment, the definition of environment governs what kinds of harm can be criminalized. While there is no accepted definition of the environment in international law, the International Expert Panel for the Legal Definition of Ecocide follows the language of the Environmental Modification Convention to define the โenvironmentโ as โthe earth, its biosphere, cryosphere, lithosphere, hydrosphere and atmosphere, as well as outer spaceโ.
The International Law Commission and the International Committee of the Red Cross both consider that the concept of the environment includes both human and natural elements as they constitute a complex system of interconnections that cannot be treated as discrete.
April 24: Armenian Genocide Memorial Day
April 24: Armenian Genocide Memorial Day
Today, April 24th, marks Armenian Genocide Memorial Day, an annual day of remembrance for the victims of the Armenian Genocide of 1915. This tragic chapter in history saw the systematic mass killings and starvation of approximately 1.5 million Armenians by the Ottoman Empire, motivated by ethnic and religious intolerance.
The Promise Institute was founded in honor of those who perished, to work towards a world in which such atrocities are never repeated.
๐ Understanding the Elements of Ecocide Law: A Seven-Part Series ๐
Part 1: The Treshold Of Harm
This series breaks down the seven key elements of adopted and proposed ecocide legislation, why they matter and how they have changed in comparison to the international proposal.
Xuchen Zhang and Kate Mackintosh conducted an extensive comparison of existing and proposed laws. In this series, we present their findings in bite-sized pieces, examining each element in detail to highlight its significance.
A Practical Guide for Transposing the ECDโs Qualified Offence
A Practical Guide for Transposing the ECDโs Qualified Offence
EU Directive 2024/1203 on the protection of the environment through criminal law (ECD) came into force on 20 May 2024. It requires all EU Member States to introduce national laws addressing environmental crimes, including the most serious casesโso-called โqualified offences,โ which may closely resemble ecocide.
Human Rights at Sea: Contemporary Challenges
Our Legal Associate Amanda Brown, a doctoral researcher at SOAS University of London, joined the expert panel on Human Rights at Sea: Contemporary Challenges, co-hosted by the Hellenic Branch of the International Law Association and the Athens Public International Law Center, where she spoke about the challenges of documenting human rights violations at sea, with a specific focus on Greeceโs systematic practice of expelling asylum seekers into Turkish waters.
Ecocide Law Advisory Launch
On February 12, we gathered at the Asser Institute in The Hague for the launch of Ecocide Law Advisory (ELA) and the Manual on the National Criminalisation of Ecocideโtwo initiatives dedicated to advancing the effective criminalization of ecocide at national and international levels.
Meet the Team
Xuchen is part of the team that works with the ICC OTP to develop a policy paper on accountability for environmental crimes under the Rome Statute, and she is on the roster of Ecocide Law Advisory. She also contributed to our submission on the Gaza conflict to the Arms Trade Treaty Working Group, and our brief on the UK water crisis for the UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to a clean, healthy and sustainable environment. Most recently, she has co-authored an article comparing new and proposed national ecocide laws with executive director Kate Mackintosh which is pending publication.